After obtaining the jug, Ichabod took it back to the archives. According to legend, Orpheus used the Jug to find a lost individual in the Underworld. He desperately starts looking for spells to find Abbie, and Joe points out that it’s been a month since she disappeared. Ichabod goes to the Tree of Fear and begins the ritual with the Jug. Nothing happens, he angrily knocks the Jug aside. Ichabod wonders where Abbie is. As Ichabod leaves, energy emerges from the Jug and lights up a root of the tree... leaving a face behind. After this, Abbie returns on her own accords and sometime, the jug is retrieved from Pandora's Hideout.
While trying to figure out how to get to the Catacombs, Abbie gets out the Jug that Ichabod used to find her. She has followed up on Ichabod's research and discovered that Orpheus used a lyre with golden thread. Ichabod figures that the thread sewn into the flag let them enter into the Catacombs, and the last time he saw it was with Paul.
|"I, Witness"||"Whispers in the Dark"||"Blood and Fear"||"The Sisters Mills"||"Dead Men Tell No Tales"|
|"This Red Lady from Caribee"||"The Art of War"||"Novus Ordo Seclorum"||"One Life"||"Incident At Stone Manor"|
|"Kindred Spirits"||"Sins of the Father"||"Dark Mirror"||"Into the Wild"||"Incommunicado"|
|"Dawn's Early Light"||"Delaware"||"Ragnarok"|